- High resource consumption: Information and communication technologies are responsible for around 8 % of Germany’s CO2 emissions and consume valuable raw materials like precious metals and rare earths.
- Cutting emissions in half: Extending smartphone usage to 5 – 7 years could sink greenhouse gas emissions from smartphones by 50 %; the current average usage span is 2.5 years.
- Take advantage of potential: Over 60 % of consumers are open to using their mobile phones for longer or to the purchase of refurbished devices.
In a world in which every moment counts and connectivity is everything, smartphones have a come to play an all-important role in our daily lives. Around 20 million smartphones are sold each year in Germany, as Bitkom recently reported. Yet this extreme level of consumption has a significant impact on our environment and climate. A study commissioned by the German Federation for the Environment and Nature Conservation focusing on the CO2 footprint of digital technologies shows that around 8 percent of Germany’s average CO2 emissions come from information and communication technologies. The high consumption of valuable raw materials like precious metals and rare earths exacerbates the problem.
The discussion paper “Circularity as the Service”, published today by the Wuppertal Institute and commissioned by the Vodafone Institute, offers the first comprehensive overview of the entire smartphone lifecycle. It identifies strategies for how the smartphone industry can extend device life spans and reduce their ecological footprints.
Extending smartphone usage spans
The discussion paper examined studies and data pertaining to the lifespans and usage spans of smartphones. In doing so, the potential for extending device usage spans became clear: An average usage span of five to seven years could reduce the greenhouse gas emissions from smartphones by around half. Currently, smartphones in Germany are replaced after an average of 2.5 years. Were that usage span to be lengthened, demand for new devices could be significantly reduced, which would translate into economic advantages for consumers in addition to the environmental benefits. Consumers would also prefer to use their smartphones for longer. According to a survey conducted in Austria, smartphone users would like to see device lifespans of around five years.
Dr Julia Reinhard, a researcher in the Digital Transformation research department of the Wuppertal Institute and lead author of this discussion paper, says: “It is worth taking a closer look – because the standard smartphone lifecycle has thus far primarily served the target group of tech enthusiasts and those with a distinct sense for aesthetics.” Those two groups are particularly interested in new models and the most up-to-date technology. But other target groups, like pragmatists, sustainability enthusiasts, price-sensitive users and long-term users are open to using their smartphones for longer and to the purchase of refurbished devices. “Current business models, however, do not sufficiently exploit these groups, which make up an estimated user share of 60 percent,” Reinhard criticises.
New business models are needed
The key to extending smartphone usage lies in adjusting the business model along the entire value-added chain. According to the Environmental Product Declaration of producers like Apple, around 80 percent of CO2 emissions occur during the production phase. As such, producers should focus more on repairability and durability. This includes the design of modular smartphones that can be repaired more easily and the availability of affordable and readily available replacement parts. According to the discussion paper authors, security updates over a period of at least seven years are also crucial. Currently, however, such update periods are only four years for Android and six years for Apple devices.
Promote circularity and extend smartphone lifecycles
Economic models focused on circularity are essential for extending smartphone lifecycles. These include the expansion of repair services and increased offerings of refurbished devices by retailers and telecommunications providers. The professional collection and recycling of devices that have reached the end of their lifecycle must also become standard, in order to recover the – according to a Bitkom estimate – 210 million unused mobile devices languishing in drawers in Germany.
An appeal for a sustainable transformation
The authors of the discussion paper believe the onus is primarily on the industry and on policymakers to work towards a more sustainable use of smartphones. Strategies for extending smartphone usage spans must focus on consumers, but also on the entire smartphone system – including manufacturers, service providers and other market stakeholders. Only then can a sustainable transformation in the production and usage of smartphones be achieved.
“The extension of smartphone usage offers an enormous opportunity to reduce CO2 emissions and protect valuable resources. At the Vodafone Institute, we are committed to ensuring that the sector exploits this potential and focuses squarely on sustainability. It is time for business models to be reconsidered and consumer needs to be prioritised to shape a more environmentally friendly future together,” says Christina Arens, head of the Vodafone Institute.
Wuppertal Institut für Klima, Umwelt, Energie gGmbH
The Wuppertal Institute is an implementation-oriented research institute for sustainability and transformation research with a focus on impact and practical application. Since its foundation in 1991, the institute’s core mission has been to contribute to the achievement of global sustainability goals on the basis of scientific evidence. Particular emphasis lies on showcasing and shaping transformation processes for a climate-friendly and resource-efficient world. The work of the Institute’s scientists includes researching system knowledge, target knowledge, and transformation knowledge and developing practical guidelines and strategies to support business, politics and society – at a local level, in Germany, in Europe and all around the world. wupperinst.org
